{ "run": 536, "n_metros": 186, "windows": { "pre": [ "2015-01", "2020-02" ], "acute": [ "2020-03", "2022-12" ], "recent": [ "2023-01", "2026-07" ] }, "mean_gap_pct_pts": { "pre": -0.834, "acute": -0.0622, "recent": 0.1565 }, "era_vs_zero": { "pre": { "label": "pre-COVID gap vs zero", "n": 186, "mean": -0.834, "p": 8.087837152804037e-14, "ci95": [ -1.0529, -0.6151 ] }, "acute": { "label": "acute-COVID gap vs zero", "n": 186, "mean": -0.0622, "p": 0.6807025075090544, "ci95": [ -0.3586, 0.2341 ] }, "recent": { "label": "2023-2026 gap vs zero", "n": 186, "mean": 0.1565, "p": 0.06377009584221151, "ci95": [ -0.009, 0.3219 ] } }, "formal_spec": { "label": "monthly panel: metro-city log-return spread ~ post-COVID dummy, clustered by metro", "n": 38160, "n_metros": 120, "slope": 0.0252, "r2": 0.00144, "p": 0.017505462712895443, "ci95": [ 0.0044, 0.046 ] }, "share_metros_positive_gap": { "pre": 0.2742, "acute": 0.4839, "recent": 0.586 }, "test_pre_vs_acute": { "label": "acute minus pre (did the gap open?)", "n": 186, "mean": 0.7718, "p": 5.822232130489433e-06, "ci95": [ 0.4381, 1.1055 ], "bootstrap_ci95": [ 0.4467, 1.1125 ] }, "test_acute_vs_recent": { "label": "recent minus acute (has it faded?)", "n": 186, "mean": 0.2187, "p": 0.23418260771521082, "ci95": [ -0.1416, 0.5791 ], "bootstrap_ci95": [ -0.1207, 0.5938 ] }, "test_pre_vs_recent": { "label": "recent minus pre (net effect today)", "n": 186, "mean": 0.9905, "p": 7.888253125336351e-12, "ci95": [ 0.7067, 1.2743 ], "bootstrap_ci95": [ 0.7163, 1.2761 ] }, "table": [ { "metro_id": 394913, "city_id": 6181, "name": "New York, NY", "metro_growth_pre": 4.399136876049754, "city_growth_pre": 6.70387872059078, "gap_pre": -2.3047418445410264, "metro_growth_acute": 8.393893793339355, "city_growth_acute": 4.5690484872443315, "gap_acute": 3.824845306095024, "metro_growth_recent": 5.071002533572738, "city_growth_recent": 2.4957862856683164, "gap_recent": 2.5752162479044216 }, { "metro_id": 753899, "city_id": 12447, "name": "Los Angeles, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 6.6228540252713035, "city_growth_pre": 7.7858256416991445, "gap_pre": -1.162971616427841, "metro_growth_acute": 12.731449653334368, "city_growth_acute": 11.899016113815845, "gap_acute": 0.8324335395185223, "metro_growth_recent": 2.994697720629382, "city_growth_recent": 0.9871561546964098, "gap_recent": 2.0075415659329723 }, { "metro_id": 394463, "city_id": 17426, "name": "Chicago, IL", "metro_growth_pre": 4.295500631329264, "city_growth_pre": 4.024943761219346, "gap_pre": 0.27055687010991836, "metro_growth_acute": 9.10410622053793, "city_growth_acute": 5.388430454432631, "gap_acute": 3.7156757661053, "metro_growth_recent": 4.790204582650991, "city_growth_recent": 2.818179844069851, "gap_recent": 1.9720247385811396 }, { "metro_id": 394514, "city_id": 38128, "name": "Dallas, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 8.025714896735733, "city_growth_pre": 10.963087973647477, "gap_pre": -2.9373730769117437, "metro_growth_acute": 17.135947122819108, "city_growth_acute": 14.810423398233569, "gap_acute": 2.3255237245855387, "metro_growth_recent": -1.7049533167660866, "city_growth_recent": -1.7856313662685117, "gap_recent": 0.08067804950242508 }, { "metro_id": 394692, "city_id": 39051, "name": "Houston, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 4.258860893680496, "city_growth_pre": 5.28140771192956, "gap_pre": -1.0225468182490642, "metro_growth_acute": 14.162027482898498, "city_growth_acute": 13.699363210605531, "gap_acute": 0.462664272292967, "metro_growth_recent": -0.6703555760224629, "city_growth_recent": -1.045792348807014, "gap_recent": 0.3754367727845511 }, { "metro_id": 395209, "city_id": 41568, "name": "Washington, DC", "metro_growth_pre": 3.140046848711825, "city_growth_pre": 4.280527846378319, "gap_pre": -1.1404809976664936, "metro_growth_acute": 8.59631835562699, "city_growth_acute": 3.3438653527716937, "gap_acute": 5.252453002855296, "metro_growth_recent": 2.28413407608905, "city_growth_recent": -2.62249108978972, "gap_recent": 4.90662516587877 }, { "metro_id": 394974, "city_id": 13271, "name": "Philadelphia, PA", "metro_growth_pre": 4.003202072573969, "city_growth_pre": 9.10984855021756, "gap_pre": -5.106646477643591, "metro_growth_acute": 10.623314802376761, "city_growth_acute": 6.918785937279866, "gap_acute": 3.7045288650968953, "metro_growth_recent": 4.227639847640255, "city_growth_recent": 2.366502234119008, "gap_recent": 1.861137613521247 }, { "metro_id": 394856, "city_id": 12700, "name": "Miami, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 6.92530371669891, "city_growth_pre": 4.212896823896307, "gap_pre": 2.712406892802603, "metro_growth_acute": 17.013751084633157, "city_growth_acute": 16.136686881906087, "gap_acute": 0.8770642027270696, "metro_growth_recent": 0.2283274044985403, "city_growth_recent": 2.2811542653355703, "gap_recent": -2.05282686083703 }, { "metro_id": 394347, "city_id": 37211, "name": "Atlanta, GA", "metro_growth_pre": 7.664954693796072, "city_growth_pre": 10.23016414747354, "gap_pre": -2.5652094536774674, "metro_growth_acute": 17.957718221927426, "city_growth_acute": 10.849130319839164, "gap_acute": 7.108587902088262, "metro_growth_recent": -0.21047571363991116, "city_growth_recent": -2.1714407033485994, "gap_recent": 1.9609649897086883 }, { "metro_id": 394404, "city_id": 44269, "name": "Boston, MA", "metro_growth_pre": 5.6299012259666235, "city_growth_pre": 6.557547762205268, "gap_pre": -0.9276465362386448, "metro_growth_acute": 10.095005010081127, "city_growth_acute": 5.092096784110678, "gap_acute": 5.002908225970449, "metro_growth_recent": 3.989576729027734, "city_growth_recent": 1.9215531287646253, "gap_recent": 2.0680236002631087 }, { "metro_id": 394976, "city_id": 40326, "name": "Phoenix, AZ", "metro_growth_pre": 7.087640930252452, "city_growth_pre": 8.086414133923801, "gap_pre": -0.998773203671349, "metro_growth_acute": 20.330830310195275, "city_growth_acute": 20.485816319175225, "gap_acute": -0.15498600897995018, "metro_growth_recent": -0.6380113320507715, "city_growth_recent": -0.7762627154950413, "gap_recent": 0.1382513834442698 }, { "metro_id": 395057, "city_id": 20330, "name": "San Francisco, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 6.6557506653808804, "city_growth_pre": 4.915810218495673, "gap_pre": 1.7399404468852078, "metro_growth_acute": 10.620005527850527, "city_growth_acute": 2.8987624431232635, "gap_acute": 7.721243084727263, "metro_growth_recent": 0.4553071395613688, "city_growth_recent": 1.5889414634329004, "gap_recent": -1.1336343238715316 }, { "metro_id": 395025, "city_id": 47401, "name": "Riverside, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 6.802228735489449, "city_growth_pre": 6.234953186174375, "gap_pre": 0.5672755493150738, "metro_growth_acute": 16.979931736931043, "city_growth_acute": 15.213894354493101, "gap_acute": 1.7660373824379416, "metro_growth_recent": 1.4470444229854793, "city_growth_recent": 1.9691329085439149, "gap_recent": -0.5220884855584356 }, { "metro_id": 394532, "city_id": 17762, "name": "Detroit, MI", "metro_growth_pre": 7.943914936690005, "city_growth_pre": 13.10506499252824, "gap_pre": -5.161150055838235, "metro_growth_acute": 10.708543656515726, "city_growth_acute": 18.230005056507512, "gap_acute": -7.521461399991786, "metro_growth_recent": 4.035542543470367, "city_growth_recent": 1.1751144230055695, "gap_recent": 2.8604281204647974 }, { "metro_id": 395078, "city_id": 16037, "name": "Seattle, WA", "metro_growth_pre": 9.417924782775081, "city_growth_pre": 9.256510698496756, "gap_pre": 0.16141408427832538, "metro_growth_acute": 14.684565903338093, "city_growth_acute": 9.21463731853155, "gap_acute": 5.469928584806544, "metro_growth_recent": 1.8478080088065907, "city_growth_recent": 0.607239985528246, "gap_recent": 1.2405680232783447 }, { "metro_id": 394865, "city_id": 5983, "name": "Minneapolis, MN", "metro_growth_pre": 6.109772786757399, "city_growth_pre": 7.303940800320296, "gap_pre": -1.194168013562897, "metro_growth_acute": 9.233123844973605, "city_growth_acute": 4.768425773754879, "gap_acute": 4.464698071218725, "metro_growth_recent": 1.6784422383195101, "city_growth_recent": 1.3225056175618277, "gap_recent": 0.3559366207576824 }, { "metro_id": 395056, "city_id": 54296, "name": "San Diego, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 5.629052548907254, "city_growth_pre": 5.72024412314379, "gap_pre": -0.09119157423653679, "metro_growth_acute": 15.677358122400431, "city_growth_acute": 15.881992843894881, "gap_acute": -0.2046347214944504, "metro_growth_recent": 2.5664753932559905, "city_growth_recent": 2.0514261149787947, "gap_recent": 0.5150492782771958 }, { "metro_id": 395148, "city_id": 41176, "name": "Tampa, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 8.32406726574636, "city_growth_pre": 10.019235694645538, "gap_pre": -1.6951684288991782, "metro_growth_acute": 20.643379764589508, "city_growth_acute": 19.613979358333268, "gap_acute": 1.02940040625624, "metro_growth_recent": -2.2336609031910974, "city_growth_recent": -0.9689072031846012, "gap_recent": -1.2647537000064961 }, { "metro_id": 394530, "city_id": 11093, "name": "Denver, CO", "metro_growth_pre": 7.493900893710266, "city_growth_pre": 7.5016109251050285, "gap_pre": -0.007710031394762673, "metro_growth_acute": 13.75882388911395, "city_growth_acute": 11.809936743667393, "gap_acute": 1.948887145446557, "metro_growth_recent": -0.8869208735431715, "city_growth_recent": -2.4053674396712283, "gap_recent": 1.5184465661280568 }, { "metro_id": 394358, "city_id": 3523, "name": "Baltimore, MD", "metro_growth_pre": 2.8266403062972203, "city_growth_pre": 6.31443914850041, "gap_pre": -3.48779884220319, "metro_growth_acute": 8.498423933324313, "city_growth_acute": 10.095098625430694, "gap_acute": -1.5966746921063812, "metro_growth_recent": 2.3907171283494737, "city_growth_recent": 1.1699804937027336, "gap_recent": 1.22073663464674 }, { "metro_id": 394943, "city_id": 13121, "name": "Orlando, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 7.846033455864928, "city_growth_pre": 8.604167153209206, "gap_pre": -0.7581336973442774, "metro_growth_acute": 17.376470289882004, "city_growth_acute": 16.70999269915468, "gap_acute": 0.6664775907273253, "metro_growth_recent": -0.981771933164414, "city_growth_recent": -0.4155614297019249, "gap_recent": -0.5662105034624891 }, { "metro_id": 394458, "city_id": 24043, "name": "Charlotte, NC", "metro_growth_pre": 7.397531103004369, "city_growth_pre": 8.494347060017628, "gap_pre": -1.0968159570132583, "metro_growth_acute": 18.348342154757564, "city_growth_acute": 18.68415205608955, "gap_acute": -0.33580990133198796, "metro_growth_recent": 1.1595644200076205, "city_growth_recent": 0.7066251533473099, "gap_recent": 0.4529392666603106 }, { "metro_id": 395055, "city_id": 6915, "name": "San Antonio, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 5.591783949645691, "city_growth_pre": 6.395655014218902, "gap_pre": -0.8038710645732108, "metro_growth_acute": 14.588825664202531, "city_growth_acute": 14.244030371396867, "gap_acute": 0.3447952928056637, "metro_growth_recent": -2.5497681404026027, "city_growth_recent": -2.78709113427494, "gap_recent": 0.23732299387233713 }, { "metro_id": 394998, "city_id": 13373, "name": "Portland, OR", "metro_growth_pre": 7.122652437845654, "city_growth_pre": 5.7011475160616945, "gap_pre": 1.42150492178396, "metro_growth_acute": 12.263011532153048, "city_growth_acute": 9.181854609166853, "gap_acute": 3.081156922986194, "metro_growth_recent": 0.32390238057825027, "city_growth_recent": -0.2818399530773124, "gap_recent": 0.6057423336555627 }, { "metro_id": 395045, "city_id": 20288, "name": "Sacramento, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 6.773610882189026, "city_growth_pre": 8.486153408068596, "gap_pre": -1.7125425258795692, "metro_growth_acute": 13.80279972063239, "city_growth_acute": 14.056256480960316, "gap_acute": -0.25345676032792674, "metro_growth_recent": 0.3804674483837503, "city_growth_recent": -0.14296154827607244, "gap_recent": 0.5234289966598227 }, { "metro_id": 394982, "city_id": 26529, "name": "Pittsburgh, PA", "metro_growth_pre": 4.048751789087573, "city_growth_pre": 7.645479551031611, "gap_pre": -3.596727761944038, "metro_growth_acute": 8.558422446042533, "city_growth_acute": 8.84439959439758, "gap_acute": -0.2859771483550464, "metro_growth_recent": 2.542354637407908, "city_growth_recent": 2.0542760721547113, "gap_recent": 0.4880785652531965 }, { "metro_id": 394466, "city_id": 4099, "name": "Cincinnati, OH", "metro_growth_pre": 5.771569564985487, "city_growth_pre": 7.212001844724066, "gap_pre": -1.4404322797385785, "metro_growth_acute": 11.835522674854108, "city_growth_acute": 11.182077220702228, "gap_acute": 0.6534454541518802, "metro_growth_recent": 3.821095632979845, "city_growth_recent": 3.391751216231018, "gap_recent": 0.42934441674882695 }, { "metro_id": 394355, "city_id": 10221, "name": "Austin, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 4.524563922045931, "city_growth_pre": 4.803714385781442, "gap_pre": -0.2791504637355109, "metro_growth_acute": 22.296687937722858, "city_growth_acute": 20.54891168860439, "gap_acute": 1.7477762491184663, "metro_growth_recent": -5.230448450650426, "city_growth_recent": -5.559534764892229, "gap_recent": 0.32908631424180257 }, { "metro_id": 394775, "city_id": 18959, "name": "Las Vegas, NV", "metro_growth_pre": 9.633406514839406, "city_growth_pre": 9.829705218465689, "gap_pre": -0.1962987036262831, "metro_growth_acute": 17.159417507762342, "city_growth_acute": 17.3564233029859, "gap_acute": -0.1970057952235571, "metro_growth_recent": 1.8974324894736556, "city_growth_recent": 1.997913212138069, "gap_recent": -0.10048072266441332 }, { "metro_id": 394735, "city_id": 18795, "name": "Kansas City, MO", "metro_growth_pre": 7.025494111934745, "city_growth_pre": 8.69219742156367, "gap_pre": -1.6667033096289243, "metro_growth_acute": 12.182575918255749, "city_growth_acute": 12.679500099781556, "gap_acute": -0.49692418152580764, "metro_growth_recent": 3.2877280775063555, "city_growth_recent": 2.7300006781124004, "gap_recent": 0.5577273993939551 }, { "metro_id": 394492, "city_id": 10920, "name": "Columbus, OH", "metro_growth_pre": 6.731025393683519, "city_growth_pre": 9.178354008649478, "gap_pre": -2.4473286149659588, "metro_growth_acute": 12.754599055622442, "city_growth_acute": 13.43393117390129, "gap_acute": -0.6793321182788468, "metro_growth_recent": 2.9501654814127445, "city_growth_recent": 2.36676478787524, "gap_recent": 0.5834006935375045 }, { "metro_id": 394705, "city_id": 32149, "name": "Indianapolis, IN", "metro_growth_pre": 6.58879580635464, "city_growth_pre": 8.588522777643577, "gap_pre": -1.9997269712889372, "metro_growth_acute": 15.048347977654911, "city_growth_acute": 15.47833587678927, "gap_acute": -0.42998789913435864, "metro_growth_recent": 2.2536337439251612, "city_growth_recent": 1.7746423878497002, "gap_recent": 0.47899135607546106 }, { "metro_id": 394475, "city_id": 24115, "name": "Cleveland, OH", "metro_growth_pre": 5.358105508437316, "city_growth_pre": 8.837004658317614, "gap_pre": -3.4788991498802977, "metro_growth_acute": 11.036853550825484, "city_growth_acute": 13.222457925374473, "gap_acute": -2.185604374548989, "metro_growth_recent": 5.471869458463672, "city_growth_recent": 3.722841506559095, "gap_recent": 1.7490279519045773 }, { "metro_id": 394902, "city_id": 6118, "name": "Nashville, TN", "metro_growth_pre": 8.55547770311501, "city_growth_pre": 9.096346694600467, "gap_pre": -0.540868991485457, "metro_growth_acute": 17.41835648676106, "city_growth_acute": 16.83744827922147, "gap_acute": 0.5809082075395899, "metro_growth_recent": 0.5851707474185978, "city_growth_recent": -0.49073765483241644, "gap_recent": 1.0759084022510141 }, { "metro_id": 395194, "city_id": 41515, "name": "Virginia Beach, VA", "metro_growth_pre": 2.529724695314118, "city_growth_pre": 2.476778007243743, "gap_pre": 0.05294668807037528, "metro_growth_acute": 10.299597597570223, "city_growth_acute": 9.57561307441206, "gap_acute": 0.7239845231581636, "metro_growth_recent": 3.498489525710555, "city_growth_recent": 3.5630410777827857, "gap_recent": -0.06455155207223084 }, { "metro_id": 395005, "city_id": 26637, "name": "Providence, RI", "metro_growth_pre": 5.742808146506037, "city_growth_pre": 8.90749982101298, "gap_pre": -3.164691674506943, "metro_growth_acute": 12.53604134719625, "city_growth_acute": 12.904797521627609, "gap_acute": -0.36875617443135944, "metro_growth_recent": 5.223180122856865, "city_growth_recent": 5.341679020900791, "gap_recent": -0.1184988980439261 }, { "metro_id": 394714, "city_id": 25290, "name": "Jacksonville, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 7.285721163362548, "city_growth_pre": 8.736262039318337, "gap_pre": -1.450540875955789, "metro_growth_acute": 18.748904777359428, "city_growth_acute": 18.63203774166641, "gap_acute": 0.11686703569301926, "metro_growth_recent": -1.2699456754922929, "city_growth_recent": -1.8168052850652823, "gap_recent": 0.5468596095729894 }, { "metro_id": 394862, "city_id": 5976, "name": "Milwaukee, WI", "metro_growth_pre": 5.514294769638721, "city_growth_pre": 8.287737917791468, "gap_pre": -2.7734431481527464, "metro_growth_acute": 8.566674102432943, "city_growth_acute": 12.203488777654032, "gap_acute": -3.636814675221089, "metro_growth_recent": 5.085973923200824, "city_growth_recent": 6.3053055764990065, "gap_recent": -1.2193316532981822 }, { "metro_id": 394935, "city_id": 33225, "name": "Oklahoma City, OK", "metro_growth_pre": 3.215961008075835, "city_growth_pre": 4.456650611604928, "gap_pre": -1.240689603529093, "metro_growth_acute": 12.366481518929344, "city_growth_acute": 12.480029976159642, "gap_acute": -0.11354845723029783, "metro_growth_recent": 1.7695247817287798, "city_growth_recent": 1.0033107414610052, "gap_recent": 0.7662140402677746 }, { "metro_id": 395012, "city_id": 54047, "name": "Raleigh, NC", "metro_growth_pre": 5.690010868847435, "city_growth_pre": 6.010008069895474, "gap_pre": -0.3199972010480394, "metro_growth_acute": 18.659796853640557, "city_growth_acute": 17.61300901380248, "gap_acute": 1.0467878398380783, "metro_growth_recent": -0.21980173530091757, "city_growth_recent": -0.307181233467861, "gap_recent": 0.08737949816694346 }, { "metro_id": 394849, "city_id": 32811, "name": "Memphis, TN", "metro_growth_pre": 6.429704300337311, "city_growth_pre": 8.490210992213715, "gap_pre": -2.0605066918764043, "metro_growth_acute": 15.165841028408797, "city_growth_acute": 16.659322774738833, "gap_acute": -1.4934817463300352, "metro_growth_recent": 0.271787977052913, "city_growth_recent": -1.3636841954499572, "gap_recent": 1.6354721725028702 }, { "metro_id": 395022, "city_id": 6752, "name": "Richmond, VA", "metro_growth_pre": 5.119078753388891, "city_growth_pre": 7.670400991894656, "gap_pre": -2.5513222385057652, "metro_growth_acute": 12.08225110251558, "city_growth_acute": 12.68951897594498, "gap_acute": -0.6072678734294001, "metro_growth_recent": 3.14702718776134, "city_growth_recent": 2.6816373155206374, "gap_recent": 0.4653898722407024 }, { "metro_id": 394807, "city_id": 12455, "name": "Louisville, KY", "metro_growth_pre": 5.917962041399565, "city_growth_pre": 5.829534578001158, "gap_pre": 0.08842746339840701, "metro_growth_acute": 9.834084208386034, "city_growth_acute": 8.783641501415683, "gap_acute": 1.050442706970351, "metro_growth_recent": 3.5845233792649673, "city_growth_recent": 3.7385995406445742, "gap_recent": -0.1540761613796069 }, { "metro_id": 394910, "city_id": 19594, "name": "New Orleans, LA", "metro_growth_pre": 2.3033062833080313, "city_growth_pre": 4.30884886806848, "gap_pre": -2.005542584760449, "metro_growth_acute": 6.7575335809067845, "city_growth_acute": 8.195867415540341, "gap_acute": -1.438333834633557, "metro_growth_recent": -2.2499817383969516, "city_growth_recent": -4.460185666183482, "gap_recent": 2.21020392778653 }, { "metro_id": 395053, "city_id": 6909, "name": "Salt Lake City, UT", "metro_growth_pre": 8.228959734516646, "city_growth_pre": 9.286198558228296, "gap_pre": -1.05723882371165, "metro_growth_acute": 16.97497797688371, "city_growth_acute": 15.253847804715331, "gap_acute": 1.7211301721683796, "metro_growth_recent": 1.7904754863439782, "city_growth_recent": 1.6826465899190914, "gap_recent": 0.1078288964248868 }, { "metro_id": 394669, "city_id": 5071, "name": "Hartford, CT", "metro_growth_pre": 1.6556628384630467, "city_growth_pre": 3.7440763364403535, "gap_pre": -2.0884134979773066, "metro_growth_acute": 11.156757946087072, "city_growth_acute": 9.595397118041957, "gap_acute": 1.5613608280451157, "metro_growth_recent": 6.740904602187108, "city_growth_recent": 6.131009633924908, "gap_recent": 0.6098949682621999 }, { "metro_id": 394425, "city_id": 17222, "name": "Buffalo, NY", "metro_growth_pre": 5.862469283892985, "city_growth_pre": 11.198444562288724, "gap_pre": -5.33597527839574, "metro_growth_acute": 12.596988519194454, "city_growth_acute": 14.280649336801401, "gap_acute": -1.6836608176069472, "metro_growth_recent": 4.9947405566732925, "city_growth_recent": 4.962088633876284, "gap_recent": 0.032651922797008126 }, { "metro_id": 394388, "city_id": 10417, "name": "Birmingham, AL", "metro_growth_pre": 4.390893874508413, "city_growth_pre": 3.884729408079733, "gap_pre": 0.5061644664286802, "metro_growth_acute": 12.709773131790595, "city_growth_acute": 17.75794863104712, "gap_acute": -5.048175499256526, "metro_growth_recent": 0.5749266696889797, "city_growth_recent": -3.6209740984945706, "gap_recent": 4.1959007681835505 }, { "metro_id": 394640, "city_id": 11671, "name": "Grand Rapids, MI", "metro_growth_pre": 7.697057689680324, "city_growth_pre": 10.588889215410632, "gap_pre": -2.891831525730307, "metro_growth_acute": 13.18988690506647, "city_growth_acute": 13.377400413109955, "gap_acute": -0.18751350804348554, "metro_growth_recent": 4.472625751015593, "city_growth_recent": 3.940810881883669, "gap_recent": 0.5318148691319236 }, { "metro_id": 395167, "city_id": 7481, "name": "Tucson, AZ", "metro_growth_pre": 6.093773451317954, "city_growth_pre": 6.338581047257506, "gap_pre": -0.2448075959395517, "metro_growth_acute": 17.24866715459345, "city_growth_acute": 17.409147814591826, "gap_acute": -0.16048065999837746, "metro_growth_recent": -0.2947718394249144, "city_growth_recent": -0.19224283551109217, "gap_recent": -0.10252900391382225 }, { "metro_id": 395169, "city_id": 20859, "name": "Tulsa, OK", "metro_growth_pre": 3.6339833736247615, "city_growth_pre": 4.239235679275687, "gap_pre": -0.6052523056509256, "metro_growth_acute": 13.086798962668974, "city_growth_acute": 13.091305380678358, "gap_acute": -0.004506418009384561, "metro_growth_recent": 3.15894419897653, "city_growth_recent": 3.502173436641369, "gap_recent": -0.3432292376648389 }, { "metro_id": 394619, "city_id": 18203, "name": "Fresno, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 7.273343134594453, "city_growth_pre": 7.752805829071787, "gap_pre": -0.47946269447733414, "metro_growth_acute": 14.609275629025806, "city_growth_acute": 14.762892862892787, "gap_acute": -0.15361723386698145, "metro_growth_recent": 2.217461382626871, "city_growth_recent": 2.0983657334788157, "gap_recent": 0.11909564914805548 }, { "metro_id": 395238, "city_id": 14724, "name": "Worcester, MA", "metro_growth_pre": 5.6510027448916595, "city_growth_pre": 7.021373699386996, "gap_pre": -1.3703709544953364, "metro_growth_acute": 12.13234395767819, "city_growth_acute": 13.229995511948806, "gap_acute": -1.097651554270616, "metro_growth_recent": 4.740529729512434, "city_growth_recent": 4.371433442471969, "gap_recent": 0.36909628704046504 }, { "metro_id": 394938, "city_id": 40152, "name": "Omaha, NE", "metro_growth_pre": 5.881467054736131, "city_growth_pre": 6.2337129453013835, "gap_pre": -0.3522458905652526, "metro_growth_acute": 11.319994153984096, "city_growth_acute": 11.62606339576359, "gap_acute": -0.30606924177949324, "metro_growth_recent": 2.6216866790366815, "city_growth_recent": 2.1781052347535796, "gap_recent": 0.44358144428310187 }, { "metro_id": 394415, "city_id": 3806, "name": "Bridgeport, CT", "metro_growth_pre": 0.9045135823064462, "city_growth_pre": 8.181254567736076, "gap_pre": -7.27674098542963, "metro_growth_acute": 12.017076639604712, "city_growth_acute": 15.45126895865064, "gap_acute": -3.4341923190459287, "metro_growth_recent": 5.610683393465978, "city_growth_recent": 6.493205964881225, "gap_recent": -0.8825225714152474 }, { "metro_id": 394653, "city_id": 24960, "name": "Greenville, SC", "metro_growth_pre": 6.091733644965479, "city_growth_pre": 7.694803359552416, "gap_pre": -1.6030697145869368, "metro_growth_acute": 14.396411983593168, "city_growth_acute": 13.16441373798328, "gap_acute": 1.2319982456098888, "metro_growth_recent": 1.9390831720645014, "city_growth_recent": 2.2896448324270886, "gap_recent": -0.3505616603625872 }, { "metro_id": 394312, "city_id": 23429, "name": "Albuquerque, NM", "metro_growth_pre": 4.319088332331651, "city_growth_pre": 4.053305000828382, "gap_pre": 0.26578333150326916, "metro_growth_acute": 15.094241025956459, "city_growth_acute": 14.823148049577926, "gap_acute": 0.271092976378533, "metro_growth_recent": 3.16504214261926, "city_growth_recent": 3.2500837135846012, "gap_recent": -0.08504157096534115 }, { "metro_id": 394357, "city_id": 3506, "name": "Bakersfield, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 5.498099804278947, "city_growth_pre": 3.827146329007546, "gap_pre": 1.6709534752714013, "metro_growth_acute": 14.946574036520715, "city_growth_acute": 15.63608724533268, "gap_acute": -0.6895132088119649, "metro_growth_recent": 2.8786576391297984, "city_growth_recent": 2.6420529263924837, "gap_recent": 0.23660471273731476 }, { "metro_id": 394308, "city_id": 37074, "name": "Albany, NY", "metro_growth_pre": 3.5841441447194575, "city_growth_pre": 3.5197928711313415, "gap_pre": 0.06435127358811599, "metro_growth_acute": 10.048651403588485, "city_growth_acute": 9.662094723380733, "gap_acute": 0.386556680207752, "metro_growth_recent": 5.047753084884679, "city_growth_recent": 5.488857618708334, "gap_recent": -0.4411045338236548 }, { "metro_id": 394753, "city_id": 25428, "name": "Knoxville, TN", "metro_growth_pre": 5.589680116149568, "city_growth_pre": 5.498544306717925, "gap_pre": 0.09113580943164301, "metro_growth_acute": 17.99120370703132, "city_growth_acute": 18.814846705314103, "gap_acute": -0.8236429982827822, "metro_growth_recent": 3.7835326182142075, "city_growth_recent": 3.5102439665014176, "gap_recent": 0.27328865171278993 }, { "metro_id": 394367, "city_id": 44055, "name": "Baton Rouge, LA", "metro_growth_pre": 2.1134926027825367, "city_growth_pre": 3.0268407751126905, "gap_pre": -0.9133481723301538, "metro_growth_acute": 6.623357349618058, "city_growth_acute": 6.236027380804493, "gap_acute": 0.38732996881356563, "metro_growth_recent": 1.1871586991868572, "city_growth_recent": 0.4031027277695211, "gap_recent": 0.7840559714173361 }, { "metro_id": 394843, "city_id": 25818, "name": "McAllen, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 4.55903898614843, "city_growth_pre": 4.073543794802585, "gap_pre": 0.4854951913458443, "metro_growth_acute": 14.608728729838885, "city_growth_acute": 14.15315943682497, "gap_acute": 0.4555692930139159, "metro_growth_recent": 1.7733512495902561, "city_growth_recent": 1.259785637174528, "gap_recent": 0.5135656124157282 }, { "metro_id": 394908, "city_id": 6155, "name": "New Haven, CT", "metro_growth_pre": 2.1455514299278033, "city_growth_pre": 3.2019844009198897, "gap_pre": -1.0564329709920863, "metro_growth_acute": 12.934138374409018, "city_growth_acute": 12.45759147844709, "gap_acute": 0.4765468959619277, "metro_growth_recent": 6.128613482102714, "city_growth_recent": 6.0282921630446715, "gap_recent": 0.10032131905804231 }, { "metro_id": 394561, "city_id": 17933, "name": "El Paso, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 2.431497475828408, "city_growth_pre": 2.427090286549431, "gap_pre": 0.004407189278976986, "metro_growth_acute": 13.881571565398959, "city_growth_acute": 13.889372423927659, "gap_acute": -0.007800858528700161, "metro_growth_recent": 2.7010240977159024, "city_growth_recent": 2.6880882523707585, "gap_recent": 0.012935845345143804 }, { "metro_id": 394318, "city_id": 16726, "name": "Allentown, PA", "metro_growth_pre": 3.688697561396967, "city_growth_pre": 7.971458870754702, "gap_pre": -4.282761309357735, "metro_growth_acute": 12.736795792223024, "city_growth_acute": 13.898334166765668, "gap_acute": -1.1615383745426442, "metro_growth_recent": 4.582358647997125, "city_growth_recent": 5.180139467778585, "gap_recent": -0.5977808197814607 }, { "metro_id": 394952, "city_id": 13150, "name": "Oxnard, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 4.550207255516354, "city_growth_pre": 5.347075749625947, "gap_pre": -0.7968684941095932, "metro_growth_acute": 12.534818222527011, "city_growth_acute": 12.156363814837801, "gap_acute": 0.37845440768921, "metro_growth_recent": 2.0953203750166063, "city_growth_recent": 2.3722645657425625, "gap_recent": -0.2769441907259562 }, { "metro_id": 394486, "city_id": 4174, "name": "Columbia, SC", "metro_growth_pre": 4.444749474993895, "city_growth_pre": 4.7764136604547405, "gap_pre": -0.33166418546084575, "metro_growth_acute": 14.317644696025983, "city_growth_acute": 14.602717338087572, "gap_acute": -0.2850726420615892, "metro_growth_recent": 2.3204282206086493, "city_growth_recent": 2.6428296699864298, "gap_recent": -0.3224014493777805 }, { "metro_id": 753906, "city_id": 13031, "name": "North Port, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 4.958390527715888, "city_growth_pre": 7.4137596537895005, "gap_pre": -2.455369126073612, "metro_growth_acute": 23.15313882704208, "city_growth_acute": 24.577609726529978, "gap_acute": -1.424470899487897, "metro_growth_recent": -5.681821962796544, "city_growth_recent": -7.127913010199176, "gap_recent": 1.446091047402632 }, { "metro_id": 394457, "city_id": 4054, "name": "Charleston, SC", "metro_growth_pre": 5.437864621558246, "city_growth_pre": 5.524375920005709, "gap_pre": -0.08651129844746297, "metro_growth_acute": 16.175578207645366, "city_growth_acute": 17.20348452730633, "gap_acute": -1.0279063196609641, "metro_growth_recent": 1.9445236397180126, "city_growth_recent": 3.7831368740938722, "gap_recent": -1.8386132343758597 }, { "metro_id": 394648, "city_id": 11722, "name": "Greensboro, NC", "metro_growth_pre": 5.848491384589629, "city_growth_pre": 5.9271720223972775, "gap_pre": -0.07868063780764878, "metro_growth_acute": 13.443224933861368, "city_growth_acute": 14.67745713314437, "gap_acute": -1.234232199283003, "metro_growth_recent": 2.3947713964536343, "city_growth_recent": 1.9379401655054929, "gap_recent": 0.4568312309481415 }, { "metro_id": 395134, "city_id": 7266, "name": "Stockton, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 8.299364213673224, "city_growth_pre": 10.208445489577938, "gap_pre": -1.9090812759047147, "metro_growth_acute": 14.620979563751796, "city_growth_acute": 14.855354689577908, "gap_acute": -0.2343751258261122, "metro_growth_recent": -0.2876052341775618, "city_growth_recent": -0.35693700891162805, "gap_recent": 0.06933177473406626 }, { "metro_id": 394440, "city_id": 30742, "name": "Cape Coral, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 4.755579514382173, "city_growth_pre": 5.7324724890948655, "gap_pre": -0.9768929747126922, "metro_growth_acute": 23.585721255436304, "city_growth_acute": 25.327502707975214, "gap_acute": -1.741781452538909, "metro_growth_recent": -6.420704655102724, "city_growth_recent": -6.935065197543398, "gap_recent": 0.5143605424406745 }, { "metro_id": 394484, "city_id": 4172, "name": "Colorado Springs, CO", "metro_growth_pre": 8.189421342886236, "city_growth_pre": 8.373566327283044, "gap_pre": -0.1841449843968075, "metro_growth_acute": 14.184923937306253, "city_growth_acute": 14.172907230806311, "gap_acute": 0.012016706499942131, "metro_growth_recent": -0.6405435238201965, "city_growth_recent": -0.8282432169267236, "gap_recent": 0.18769969310652712 }, { "metro_id": 394798, "city_id": 52998, "name": "Little Rock, AR", "metro_growth_pre": 1.958172733114159, "city_growth_pre": 1.2817645702431837, "gap_pre": 0.6764081628709753, "metro_growth_acute": 10.259988682036065, "city_growth_acute": 9.621089565490426, "gap_acute": 0.6388991165456392, "metro_growth_recent": 2.5286561934756824, "city_growth_recent": 2.1216160907603436, "gap_recent": 0.40704010271533875 }, { "metro_id": 394766, "city_id": 25483, "name": "Lakeland, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 8.67692000946143, "city_growth_pre": 9.321067436006944, "gap_pre": -0.6441474265455138, "metro_growth_acute": 19.78691570355805, "city_growth_acute": 19.448162455143965, "gap_acute": 0.33875324841408627, "metro_growth_recent": -2.0619805514870873, "city_growth_recent": -1.1521470935667395, "gap_recent": -0.9098334579203478 }, { "metro_id": 394304, "city_id": 30141, "name": "Akron, OH", "metro_growth_pre": 5.238374446448156, "city_growth_pre": 7.4624082607492355, "gap_pre": -2.2240338143010794, "metro_growth_acute": 10.32198106508459, "city_growth_acute": 13.290401086952079, "gap_acute": -2.968420021867489, "metro_growth_recent": 5.128419524314866, "city_growth_recent": 4.780740201669405, "gap_recent": 0.34767932264546086 }, { "metro_id": 394531, "city_id": 17759, "name": "Des Moines, IA", "metro_growth_pre": 5.3716669801602395, "city_growth_pre": 7.065584555228802, "gap_pre": -1.6939175750685624, "metro_growth_acute": 9.405506956591699, "city_growth_acute": 9.533111458335869, "gap_acute": -0.1276045017441696, "metro_growth_recent": 2.522766440045405, "city_growth_recent": 3.079763122382451, "gap_recent": -0.5569966823370462 }, { "metro_id": 395115, "city_id": 7221, "name": "Springfield, MA", "metro_growth_pre": 3.833587552945441, "city_growth_pre": 6.505857370663858, "gap_pre": -2.6722698177184165, "metro_growth_acute": 11.126942151988448, "city_growth_acute": 14.449619635380758, "gap_acute": -3.32267748339231, "metro_growth_recent": 4.35665647542199, "city_growth_recent": 5.103315269951679, "gap_recent": -0.7466587945296892 }, { "metro_id": 394931, "city_id": 46863, "name": "Ogden, UT", "metro_growth_pre": 9.445470311029732, "city_growth_pre": 13.253208467413346, "gap_pre": -3.807738156383614, "metro_growth_acute": 17.95478684508054, "city_growth_acute": 20.350970047127667, "gap_acute": -2.3961832020471263, "metro_growth_recent": 2.3120309191796395, "city_growth_recent": 2.3041055434895044, "gap_recent": 0.007925375690135184 }, { "metro_id": 394816, "city_id": 398849, "name": "Madison, WI", "metro_growth_pre": 5.765312071482201, "city_growth_pre": 5.777191292951475, "gap_pre": -0.01187922146927356, "metro_growth_acute": 9.822446060382646, "city_growth_acute": 9.811018083582667, "gap_acute": 0.011427976799978978, "metro_growth_recent": 4.356429876576084, "city_growth_recent": 4.111731458645843, "gap_recent": 0.24469841793024116 }, { "metro_id": 394528, "city_id": 24359, "name": "Deltona, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 8.385295273246953, "city_growth_pre": 12.052700623433688, "gap_pre": -3.667405350186735, "metro_growth_acute": 19.2143616306669, "city_growth_acute": 19.398335177314415, "gap_acute": -0.18397354664751475, "metro_growth_recent": -2.3945887671837527, "city_growth_recent": -1.068163632857721, "gap_recent": -1.3264251343260316 }, { "metro_id": 395143, "city_id": 7353, "name": "Syracuse, NY", "metro_growth_pre": 3.62518909046916, "city_growth_pre": 5.617025097144798, "gap_pre": -1.991836006675638, "metro_growth_acute": 11.323955540107944, "city_growth_acute": 11.532962972052271, "gap_acute": -0.20900743194432714, "metro_growth_recent": 7.846916843119884, "city_growth_recent": 8.298671111805364, "gap_recent": -0.4517542686854794 }, { "metro_id": 395006, "city_id": 20071, "name": "Provo, UT", "metro_growth_pre": 8.32512509794547, "city_growth_pre": 9.058335461676732, "gap_pre": -0.7332103637312617, "metro_growth_acute": 17.768191008819763, "city_growth_acute": 17.07084225677898, "gap_acute": 0.6973487520407815, "metro_growth_recent": 1.6269786859172797, "city_growth_recent": 2.094578617269091, "gap_recent": -0.4675999313518111 }, { "metro_id": 395160, "city_id": 34303, "name": "Toledo, OH", "metro_growth_pre": 5.5245602320749745, "city_growth_pre": 7.049962877617717, "gap_pre": -1.5254026455427425, "metro_growth_acute": 9.32505308353579, "city_growth_acute": 12.590630466434094, "gap_acute": -3.2655773828983037, "metro_growth_recent": 4.875740782894261, "city_growth_recent": 6.089895488239947, "gap_recent": -1.2141547053456865 }, { "metro_id": 395224, "city_id": 7929, "name": "Wichita, KS", "metro_growth_pre": 4.091338125944363, "city_growth_pre": 4.137915353941438, "gap_pre": -0.04657722799707553, "metro_growth_acute": 10.952848291807413, "city_growth_acute": 10.931798303023804, "gap_acute": 0.021049988783609308, "metro_growth_recent": 3.6590125721177467, "city_growth_recent": 3.647543340652443, "gap_recent": 0.011469231465303764 }, { "metro_id": 394957, "city_id": 53787, "name": "Palm Bay, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 8.841020957504693, "city_growth_pre": 10.619514546839087, "gap_pre": -1.7784935893343938, "metro_growth_acute": 18.951719696796527, "city_growth_acute": 20.42002057686366, "gap_acute": -1.468300880067133, "metro_growth_recent": -1.860764713587551, "city_growth_recent": -2.2787873806850083, "gap_recent": 0.4180226670974574 }, { "metro_id": 394711, "city_id": 32179, "name": "Jackson, MS", "metro_growth_pre": 3.6830097435968545, "city_growth_pre": 6.051858058472271, "gap_pre": -2.3688483148754162, "metro_growth_acute": 10.576215012028891, "city_growth_acute": 18.931578732932437, "gap_acute": -8.355363720903545, "metro_growth_recent": 2.358940731359997, "city_growth_recent": -4.70792224828973, "gap_recent": 7.066862979649727 }, { "metro_id": 394666, "city_id": 11817, "name": "Harrisburg, PA", "metro_growth_pre": 3.047470305599181, "city_growth_pre": 8.047429360096938, "gap_pre": -4.999959054497757, "metro_growth_acute": 10.608787648393047, "city_growth_acute": 12.24846897023555, "gap_acute": -1.6396813218425024, "metro_growth_recent": 4.17264079599005, "city_growth_recent": 4.6341002069685455, "gap_recent": -0.4614594109784953 }, { "metro_id": 395113, "city_id": 20604, "name": "Spokane, WA", "metro_growth_pre": 9.848273944237135, "city_growth_pre": 10.658841148425635, "gap_pre": -0.8105672041884997, "metro_growth_acute": 16.795108068604257, "city_growth_acute": 16.909261487236368, "gap_acute": -0.11415341863211026, "metro_growth_recent": 0.7304237721426051, "city_growth_recent": 0.36545350832305185, "gap_recent": 0.3649702638195533 }, { "metro_id": 395075, "city_id": 20398, "name": "Scranton, PA", "metro_growth_pre": 3.0231538104770364, "city_growth_pre": 2.0771735778022773, "gap_pre": 0.9459802326747591, "metro_growth_acute": 11.26695058560087, "city_growth_acute": 12.36317829104561, "gap_acute": -1.0962277054447398, "metro_growth_recent": 5.182474888339325, "city_growth_recent": 6.926585098439769, "gap_recent": -1.7441102101004446 }, { "metro_id": 394460, "city_id": 37837, "name": "Chattanooga, TN", "metro_growth_pre": 5.867550072651668, "city_growth_pre": 6.77226083017992, "gap_pre": -0.9047107575282514, "metro_growth_acute": 14.835202582484117, "city_growth_acute": 15.154779633121132, "gap_acute": -0.31957705063701525, "metro_growth_recent": 2.2863319470255177, "city_growth_recent": 1.6849595293417305, "gap_recent": 0.6013724176837871 }, { "metro_id": 394871, "city_id": 25934, "name": "Modesto, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 7.917360099679476, "city_growth_pre": 8.540484707381506, "gap_pre": -0.6231246077020298, "metro_growth_acute": 13.980047182225949, "city_growth_acute": 14.335468181909736, "gap_acute": -0.35542099968378693, "metro_growth_recent": 1.7145495081601263, "city_growth_recent": 1.8126139614312382, "gap_recent": -0.0980644532711119 }, { "metro_id": 394997, "city_id": 40415, "name": "Portland, ME", "metro_growth_pre": 6.266590929978805, "city_growth_pre": 7.093414376902227, "gap_pre": -0.8268234469234219, "metro_growth_acute": 15.412397240497333, "city_growth_acute": 15.498635072824163, "gap_acute": -0.08623783232683024, "metro_growth_recent": 2.8472400612639137, "city_growth_recent": 2.6144843435805676, "gap_recent": 0.23275571768334613 }, { "metro_id": 395245, "city_id": 28060, "name": "Youngstown, OH", "metro_growth_pre": 4.328368007912199, "city_growth_pre": 5.8694952031901515, "gap_pre": -1.5411271952779524, "metro_growth_acute": 12.52868496146598, "city_growth_acute": 17.581140755972548, "gap_acute": -5.052455794506567, "metro_growth_recent": 6.166014717542593, "city_growth_recent": 7.757458756217188, "gap_recent": -1.5914440386745952 }, { "metro_id": 394770, "city_id": 398300, "name": "Lansing, MI", "metro_growth_pre": 6.297398901627273, "city_growth_pre": 8.329585317609954, "gap_pre": -2.0321864159826815, "metro_growth_acute": 9.474861464507594, "city_growth_acute": 10.434087627482283, "gap_acute": -0.959226162974689, "metro_growth_recent": 4.758522780631719, "city_growth_recent": 5.486446961817349, "gap_recent": -0.7279241811856298 }, { "metro_id": 394590, "city_id": 31543, "name": "Fayetteville, AR", "metro_growth_pre": 6.229569522293822, "city_growth_pre": 5.982069788767522, "gap_pre": 0.2474997335263005, "metro_growth_acute": 17.86878610031662, "city_growth_acute": 15.878106104663589, "gap_acute": 1.9906799956530303, "metro_growth_recent": 3.6704014318012645, "city_growth_recent": 3.6512817855786563, "gap_recent": 0.0191196462226082 }, { "metro_id": 394589, "city_id": 52001, "name": "Fayetteville, NC", "metro_growth_pre": 2.5041320291817404, "city_growth_pre": 2.4173557238744254, "gap_pre": 0.08677630530731495, "metro_growth_acute": 14.286143584357156, "city_growth_acute": 15.32783341159262, "gap_acute": -1.041689827235464, "metro_growth_recent": 2.5503531884450537, "city_growth_recent": 2.597366071048832, "gap_recent": -0.04701288260377856 }, { "metro_id": 394792, "city_id": 25574, "name": "Lexington, KY", "metro_growth_pre": 5.271129817554551, "city_growth_pre": 5.264028685980076, "gap_pre": 0.007101131574475339, "metro_growth_acute": 11.817755897788304, "city_growth_acute": 11.687213940474123, "gap_acute": 0.13054195731418083, "metro_growth_recent": 4.548186687527894, "city_growth_recent": 4.412947426671207, "gap_recent": 0.1352392608566868 }, { "metro_id": 394971, "city_id": 53856, "name": "Pensacola, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 6.737218787158795, "city_growth_pre": 7.42818433360538, "gap_pre": -0.6909655464465843, "metro_growth_acute": 16.76626713804361, "city_growth_acute": 16.495157470808426, "gap_acute": 0.2711096672351836, "metro_growth_recent": -0.27258602977902663, "city_growth_recent": -0.594928834758967, "gap_recent": 0.32234280497994033 }, { "metro_id": 395068, "city_id": 26967, "name": "Santa Rosa, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 6.218917767059494, "city_growth_pre": 6.3180277688900635, "gap_pre": -0.09911000183056906, "metro_growth_acute": 8.363894633752945, "city_growth_acute": 7.405175819764515, "gap_acute": 0.9587188139884306, "metro_growth_recent": -0.2981798237408772, "city_growth_recent": -0.21830331623404362, "gap_recent": -0.07987650750683359 }, { "metro_id": 395019, "city_id": 13478, "name": "Reno, NV", "metro_growth_pre": 8.97016717136746, "city_growth_pre": 9.094477781859394, "gap_pre": -0.12431061049193382, "metro_growth_acute": 16.280940293141644, "city_growth_acute": 16.067010492919074, "gap_acute": 0.21392980022256936, "metro_growth_recent": 2.040945108430799, "city_growth_recent": 2.4216974647479064, "gap_recent": -0.3807523563171076 }, { "metro_id": 394698, "city_id": 12014, "name": "Huntsville, AL", "metro_growth_pre": 3.9349344100663313, "city_growth_pre": 4.3213096105722535, "gap_pre": -0.3863752005059222, "metro_growth_acute": 16.560199832068914, "city_growth_acute": 16.464331956284767, "gap_acute": 0.09586787578414757, "metro_growth_recent": 0.27071705064496754, "city_growth_recent": -0.3975336256307831, "gap_recent": 0.6682506762757506 }, { "metro_id": 394761, "city_id": 39312, "name": "Lafayette, LA", "metro_growth_pre": -0.18520004389589673, "city_growth_pre": -0.0060892868075977545, "gap_pre": -0.17911075708829896, "metro_growth_acute": 3.6082348349797804, "city_growth_acute": 5.356744604948389, "gap_acute": -1.7485097699686087, "metro_growth_recent": -1.1474355858914886, "city_growth_recent": -1.168607807275367, "gap_recent": 0.02117222138387831 }, { "metro_id": 394898, "city_id": 46666, "name": "Myrtle Beach, SC", "metro_growth_pre": 4.523348780534501, "city_growth_pre": 4.374340483280791, "gap_pre": 0.1490082972537108, "metro_growth_acute": 18.731922109238656, "city_growth_acute": 18.593559845656042, "gap_acute": 0.13836226358261428, "metro_growth_recent": -0.6522914017499623, "city_growth_recent": -1.619895565176353, "gap_recent": 0.9676041634263907 }, { "metro_id": 395116, "city_id": 7222, "name": "Springfield, MO", "metro_growth_pre": 5.869900822273772, "city_growth_pre": 6.050208236084351, "gap_pre": -0.1803074138105787, "metro_growth_acute": 16.249244855676213, "city_growth_acute": 15.898840902929981, "gap_acute": 0.35040395274623215, "metro_growth_recent": 2.4881173393511515, "city_growth_recent": 2.6089708992538445, "gap_recent": -0.12085355990269298 }, { "metro_id": 395195, "city_id": 21114, "name": "Visalia, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 7.355390116026269, "city_growth_pre": 6.6128853792272695, "gap_pre": 0.7425047367989999, "metro_growth_acute": 14.594305769866727, "city_growth_acute": 15.335181309921126, "gap_acute": -0.7408755400543985, "metro_growth_recent": 2.6120828274260455, "city_growth_recent": 2.2236761859475105, "gap_recent": 0.388406641478535 }, { "metro_id": 394746, "city_id": 5424, "name": "Killeen, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 4.497582795512739, "city_growth_pre": 3.8130793965999663, "gap_pre": 0.6845033989127725, "metro_growth_acute": 18.707865628202274, "city_growth_acute": 19.303642481214215, "gap_acute": -0.5957768530119409, "metro_growth_recent": -1.604502816990273, "city_growth_recent": -1.457174587051181, "gap_recent": -0.14732822993909211 }, { "metro_id": 394338, "city_id": 50779, "name": "Asheville, NC", "metro_growth_pre": 6.792224809789127, "city_growth_pre": 6.934043744607221, "gap_pre": -0.14181893481809382, "metro_growth_acute": 15.293894870856947, "city_growth_acute": 14.80456326455782, "gap_acute": 0.4893316062991282, "metro_growth_recent": 0.9479136964350601, "city_growth_recent": 0.11062679832171307, "gap_recent": 0.837286898113347 }, { "metro_id": 395183, "city_id": 34520, "name": "Vallejo, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 7.425298660831353, "city_growth_pre": 9.663037073584514, "gap_pre": -2.2377384127531608, "metro_growth_acute": 12.019103354409262, "city_growth_acute": 11.946333707077038, "gap_acute": 0.07276964733222435, "metro_growth_recent": -0.3408618206125035, "city_growth_recent": -1.7765622548871687, "gap_recent": 1.4357004342746653 }, { "metro_id": 753917, "city_id": 47570, "name": "Santa Maria, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 3.8443931089204813, "city_growth_pre": 5.309205118125569, "gap_pre": -1.464812009205088, "metro_growth_acute": 17.094833652033163, "city_growth_acute": 14.745267165130334, "gap_acute": 2.3495664869028285, "metro_growth_recent": 2.9944759759224153, "city_growth_recent": 3.1096740654278987, "gap_recent": -0.11519808950548338 }, { "metro_id": 395050, "city_id": 54288, "name": "Salinas, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 6.550547609986037, "city_growth_pre": 6.8773613599548575, "gap_pre": -0.32681374996882084, "metro_growth_acute": 13.325486145732789, "city_growth_acute": 13.321901079460782, "gap_acute": 0.0035850662720076087, "metro_growth_recent": 1.5238598756893174, "city_growth_recent": 2.2410810022194627, "gap_recent": -0.7172211265301454 }, { "metro_id": 395048, "city_id": 20317, "name": "Salem, OR", "metro_growth_pre": 10.341633417872876, "city_growth_pre": 10.597844945832389, "gap_pre": -0.25621152795951296, "metro_growth_acute": 13.683690596334278, "city_growth_acute": 13.755671599938225, "gap_acute": -0.07198100360394655, "metro_growth_recent": 1.0095185757620477, "city_growth_recent": 0.944294734398813, "gap_recent": 0.06522384136323478 }, { "metro_id": 394870, "city_id": 32900, "name": "Mobile, AL", "metro_growth_pre": 4.754405816849964, "city_growth_pre": 4.496813520909518, "gap_pre": 0.2575922959404462, "metro_growth_acute": 11.489777291127684, "city_growth_acute": 11.805485404539768, "gap_acute": -0.31570811341208405, "metro_growth_recent": 1.3241698215304945, "city_growth_recent": 1.199951510719969, "gap_recent": 0.12421831081052548 }, { "metro_id": 395015, "city_id": 6696, "name": "Reading, PA", "metro_growth_pre": 4.1272153454160545, "city_growth_pre": 11.143118486678443, "gap_pre": -7.015903141262388, "metro_growth_acute": 11.809126035492874, "city_growth_acute": 13.137725629554446, "gap_acute": -1.328599594061572, "metro_growth_recent": 4.94942584281853, "city_growth_recent": 5.792909106736873, "gap_recent": -0.8434832639183432 }, { "metro_id": 394502, "city_id": 38025, "name": "Corpus Christi, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 3.674134165018638, "city_growth_pre": 3.6591755346818537, "gap_pre": 0.014958630336784129, "metro_growth_acute": 8.694542386366265, "city_growth_acute": 8.15109932580845, "gap_acute": 0.5434430605578147, "metro_growth_recent": -1.1359280109170102, "city_growth_recent": -1.0241690091889804, "gap_recent": -0.11175900172802988 }, { "metro_id": 394421, "city_id": 51167, "name": "Brownsville, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 1.254013246484261, "city_growth_pre": 1.5730778010853819, "gap_pre": -0.3190645546011208, "metro_growth_acute": 15.423379250599472, "city_growth_acute": 15.99530021873648, "gap_acute": -0.5719209681370074, "metro_growth_recent": 1.611659448136133, "city_growth_recent": 2.5716391120361703, "gap_recent": -0.9599796639000373 }, { "metro_id": 394820, "city_id": 5772, "name": "Manchester, NH", "metro_growth_pre": 5.767156403435652, "city_growth_pre": 6.467055835997221, "gap_pre": -0.6998994325615691, "metro_growth_acute": 13.652585272825313, "city_growth_acute": 13.353046006240369, "gap_acute": 0.2995392665849437, "metro_growth_recent": 4.905083820219101, "city_growth_recent": 4.83775164288355, "gap_recent": 0.06733217733555108 }, { "metro_id": 394612, "city_id": 18170, "name": "Fort Wayne, IN", "metro_growth_pre": 6.572586535128432, "city_growth_pre": 7.120857165021135, "gap_pre": -0.5482706298927038, "metro_growth_acute": 12.83732199767261, "city_growth_acute": 13.169967340451677, "gap_acute": -0.33264534277906677, "metro_growth_recent": 4.393206257306737, "city_growth_recent": 4.366624081809583, "gap_recent": 0.026582175497154026 }, { "metro_id": 394658, "city_id": 31892, "name": "Gulfport, MS", "metro_growth_pre": 4.678246525975031, "city_growth_pre": 5.258111478826878, "gap_pre": -0.5798649528518469, "metro_growth_acute": 12.14930600575268, "city_growth_acute": 12.528741348517492, "gap_acute": -0.37943534276481294, "metro_growth_recent": 1.6711527387390772, "city_growth_recent": 1.128314215406561, "gap_recent": 0.5428385233325161 }, { "metro_id": 395051, "city_id": 20322, "name": "Salisbury, MD", "metro_growth_pre": 3.111767396150699, "city_growth_pre": 3.7506895987748963, "gap_pre": -0.6389222026241974, "metro_growth_acute": 15.294426972595037, "city_growth_acute": 11.342359426952012, "gap_acute": 3.9520675456430254, "metro_growth_recent": 0.7065143548297287, "city_growth_recent": 3.4896730614977645, "gap_recent": -2.783158706668036 }, { "metro_id": 394596, "city_id": 398007, "name": "Flint, MI", "metro_growth_pre": 10.390423754140313, "city_growth_pre": 6.8996057538376325, "gap_pre": 3.4908180003026805, "metro_growth_acute": 12.221575590459407, "city_growth_acute": 23.25790675255411, "gap_acute": -11.036331162094703, "metro_growth_recent": 5.068280626501041, "city_growth_recent": 1.5200766619732256, "gap_recent": 3.5482039645278154 }, { "metro_id": 394972, "city_id": 19903, "name": "Peoria, IL", "metro_growth_pre": -0.5195737805873334, "city_growth_pre": -0.8503584196003708, "gap_pre": 0.33078463901303745, "metro_growth_acute": 8.743734410812655, "city_growth_acute": 10.317375474681146, "gap_acute": -1.5736410638684912, "metro_growth_recent": 6.849367307229845, "city_growth_recent": 7.786952462356739, "gap_recent": -0.9375851551268939 }, { "metro_id": 394439, "city_id": 51260, "name": "Canton, OH", "metro_growth_pre": 5.050299379815908, "city_growth_pre": 6.072110005783434, "gap_pre": -1.0218106259675253, "metro_growth_acute": 9.793780025541352, "city_growth_acute": 10.326051301068285, "gap_acute": -0.5322712755269325, "metro_growth_recent": 6.089958470183835, "city_growth_recent": 6.3242021830260455, "gap_recent": -0.23424371284221035 }, { "metro_id": 395070, "city_id": 47584, "name": "Savannah, GA", "metro_growth_pre": 4.148862733062254, "city_growth_pre": 4.912836611625471, "gap_pre": -0.7639738785632169, "metro_growth_acute": 15.290826248488685, "city_growth_acute": 16.277149051942036, "gap_acute": -0.9863228034533513, "metro_growth_recent": 2.226051312352976, "city_growth_recent": 1.8095765922110825, "gap_recent": 0.41647472014189346 }, { "metro_id": 394372, "city_id": 35282, "name": "Beaumont, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 5.28836453298723, "city_growth_pre": 5.059028899345639, "gap_pre": 0.2293356336415906, "metro_growth_acute": 4.600970004718334, "city_growth_acute": 4.720069148344187, "gap_acute": -0.11909914362585283, "metro_growth_recent": 0.39474317229028927, "city_growth_recent": -0.5196146897808346, "gap_recent": 0.9143578620711239 }, { "metro_id": 395096, "city_id": 40897, "name": "Shreveport, LA", "metro_growth_pre": 0.6142955098114409, "city_growth_pre": 0.9440341033845646, "gap_pre": -0.32973859357312374, "metro_growth_acute": 1.5592017188081608, "city_growth_acute": 3.3172751503441753, "gap_acute": -1.7580734315360145, "metro_growth_recent": 1.309743440447215, "city_growth_recent": 1.0349783482959345, "gap_recent": 0.27476509215128053 }, { "metro_id": 395164, "city_id": 41279, "name": "Trenton, NJ", "metro_growth_pre": 2.939472348268434, "city_growth_pre": 8.082165812825409, "gap_pre": -5.142693464556975, "metro_growth_acute": 11.3632672325486, "city_growth_acute": 13.245262322036202, "gap_acute": -1.881995089487603, "metro_growth_recent": 4.870153265276624, "city_growth_recent": 5.150552333678837, "gap_recent": -0.28039906840221285 }, { "metro_id": 394875, "city_id": 32931, "name": "Montgomery, AL", "metro_growth_pre": 1.9505069377132231, "city_growth_pre": 1.7145698695352323, "gap_pre": 0.23593706817799087, "metro_growth_acute": 10.404217604977854, "city_growth_acute": 11.753567311997804, "gap_acute": -1.3493497070199503, "metro_growth_recent": 2.6202510956034124, "city_growth_recent": 1.0391324713632912, "gap_recent": 1.5811186242401212 }, { "metro_id": 394520, "city_id": 4301, "name": "Davenport, IA", "metro_growth_pre": 2.575979836143439, "city_growth_pre": 3.3137642540077064, "gap_pre": -0.7377844178642672, "metro_growth_acute": 6.605086971147338, "city_growth_acute": 7.2614479791982305, "gap_acute": -0.6563610080508928, "metro_growth_recent": 3.034740918946698, "city_growth_recent": 2.596676590241578, "gap_recent": 0.43806432870512024 }, { "metro_id": 395146, "city_id": 47945, "name": "Tallahassee, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 5.262538652676383, "city_growth_pre": 5.054952762273225, "gap_pre": 0.20758589040315822, "metro_growth_acute": 11.657750641610942, "city_growth_acute": 10.678505531386543, "gap_acute": 0.9792451102243991, "metro_growth_recent": 1.060784070882786, "city_growth_recent": 1.1082191432293176, "gap_recent": -0.04743507234653155 }, { "metro_id": 394576, "city_id": 38438, "name": "Eugene, OR", "metro_growth_pre": 7.919255530823799, "city_growth_pre": 7.4498207183348635, "gap_pre": 0.46943481248893537, "metro_growth_acute": 13.75790614427832, "city_growth_acute": 13.654840627784573, "gap_acute": 0.1030655164937464, "metro_growth_recent": 0.7947292002803438, "city_growth_recent": 0.7872376967292181, "gap_recent": 0.007491503551125711 }, { "metro_id": 394901, "city_id": 19533, "name": "Naples, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 2.5529827564167284, "city_growth_pre": 2.6037923115783443, "gap_pre": -0.050809555161615894, "metro_growth_acute": 24.601923808389177, "city_growth_acute": 24.485524080091178, "gap_acute": 0.11639972829799916, "metro_growth_recent": -3.9137636226898858, "city_growth_recent": -3.8113490634144798, "gap_recent": -0.10241455927540599 }, { "metro_id": 394332, "city_id": 8097, "name": "Ann Arbor, MI", "metro_growth_pre": 6.0001143229738085, "city_growth_pre": 5.842694731382511, "gap_pre": 0.1574195915912977, "metro_growth_acute": 7.856356405553758, "city_growth_acute": 7.35079061035995, "gap_acute": 0.5055657951938075, "metro_growth_recent": 2.9649005729703655, "city_growth_recent": 4.022141993106807, "gap_recent": -1.0572414201364415 }, { "metro_id": 394927, "city_id": 53673, "name": "Ocala, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 8.159613543663, "city_growth_pre": 8.91944543687748, "gap_pre": -0.7598318932144803, "metro_growth_acute": 21.430387789402573, "city_growth_acute": 21.831230904032946, "gap_acute": -0.4008431146303728, "metro_growth_recent": -1.6610492651180242, "city_growth_recent": -1.885433166132454, "gap_recent": 0.22438390101442973 }, { "metro_id": 394679, "city_id": 25108, "name": "Hickory, NC", "metro_growth_pre": 6.764725381641151, "city_growth_pre": 6.005800737020907, "gap_pre": 0.7589246446202438, "metro_growth_acute": 14.948922658776262, "city_growth_acute": 15.753747264285028, "gap_acute": -0.8048246055087667, "metro_growth_recent": 3.054873444657422, "city_growth_recent": 3.0286683458135752, "gap_recent": 0.02620509884384692 }, { "metro_id": 394697, "city_id": 12012, "name": "Huntington, WV", "metro_growth_pre": 1.7540282683599189, "city_growth_pre": 2.06662202510954, "gap_pre": -0.3125937567496211, "metro_growth_acute": 8.441532672826616, "city_growth_acute": 7.499058732595193, "gap_acute": 0.9424739402314231, "metro_growth_recent": 3.5198579654460223, "city_growth_recent": 6.6990364051255815, "gap_recent": -3.1791784396795593 }, { "metro_id": 394602, "city_id": 4764, "name": "Fort Collins, CO", "metro_growth_pre": 7.141762175103783, "city_growth_pre": 6.945499044338656, "gap_pre": 0.1962631307651268, "metro_growth_acute": 12.946780115117784, "city_growth_acute": 12.514872932917187, "gap_acute": 0.43190718220059665, "metro_growth_recent": -0.05816994075294342, "city_growth_recent": 0.12404114542716684, "gap_recent": -0.18221108618011025 }, { "metro_id": 395033, "city_id": 47426, "name": "Rockford, IL", "metro_growth_pre": 7.064435283302371, "city_growth_pre": 8.355889190804671, "gap_pre": -1.2914539075022997, "metro_growth_acute": 11.634069132500896, "city_growth_acute": 12.933032301444559, "gap_acute": -1.2989631689436631, "metro_growth_recent": 8.886762341810146, "city_growth_recent": 10.054287273662398, "gap_recent": -1.1675249318522525 }, { "metro_id": 394796, "city_id": 32503, "name": "Lincoln, NE", "metro_growth_pre": 5.534097284260208, "city_growth_pre": 5.556472080422165, "gap_pre": -0.022374796161956922, "metro_growth_acute": 11.300035245690133, "city_growth_acute": 11.337275468721169, "gap_acute": -0.037240223031036024, "metro_growth_recent": 3.2666525874153307, "city_growth_recent": 3.2004226348610123, "gap_recent": 0.0662299525543184 }, { "metro_id": 394622, "city_id": 24821, "name": "Gainesville, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 6.543850461741534, "city_growth_pre": 6.7331663094629555, "gap_pre": -0.18931584772142163, "metro_growth_acute": 14.072775785241816, "city_growth_acute": 13.384848279572568, "gap_acute": 0.6879275056692489, "metro_growth_recent": 0.32746242243748114, "city_growth_recent": -0.0037660554481548187, "gap_recent": 0.331228477885636 }, { "metro_id": 394405, "city_id": 30543, "name": "Boulder, CO", "metro_growth_pre": 6.813966002596775, "city_growth_pre": 7.0067765316395745, "gap_pre": -0.1928105290427995, "metro_growth_acute": 13.892568906441177, "city_growth_acute": 13.487344073882419, "gap_acute": 0.4052248325587584, "metro_growth_recent": -1.1404357738561137, "city_growth_recent": -1.2025772752721204, "gap_recent": 0.06214150141600672 }, { "metro_id": 394646, "city_id": 45548, "name": "Green Bay, WI", "metro_growth_pre": 6.206515529519369, "city_growth_pre": 6.940693028866709, "gap_pre": -0.7341774993473393, "metro_growth_acute": 11.878809109511055, "city_growth_acute": 11.818661777092004, "gap_acute": 0.060147332419051125, "metro_growth_recent": 6.397231121460938, "city_growth_recent": 7.844195270762581, "gap_recent": -1.4469641493016434 }, { "metro_id": 394488, "city_id": 17539, "name": "Columbus, GA", "metro_growth_pre": 3.1238245484586464, "city_growth_pre": 2.7232638259265847, "gap_pre": 0.40056072253206176, "metro_growth_acute": 11.403221075116875, "city_growth_acute": 12.999772125053044, "gap_acute": -1.5965510499361688, "metro_growth_recent": 4.040034147147483, "city_growth_recent": 3.786368098402143, "gap_recent": 0.25366604874534016 }, { "metro_id": 395107, "city_id": 20555, "name": "South Bend, IN", "metro_growth_pre": 6.827275880594271, "city_growth_pre": 8.820792660097371, "gap_pre": -1.9935167795031008, "metro_growth_acute": 12.422009426999159, "city_growth_acute": 14.03831314890793, "gap_acute": -1.6163037219087713, "metro_growth_recent": 4.956304304305497, "city_growth_recent": 5.762797357941269, "gap_recent": -0.806493053635772 }, { "metro_id": 395109, "city_id": 7191, "name": "Spartanburg, SC", "metro_growth_pre": 6.448122506837244, "city_growth_pre": 7.363667551621537, "gap_pre": -0.9155450447842934, "metro_growth_acute": 15.616194849757573, "city_growth_acute": 15.088434770344392, "gap_acute": 0.5277600794131807, "metro_growth_recent": 2.8634277006536872, "city_growth_recent": 3.1443968440495955, "gap_recent": -0.2809691433959083 }, { "metro_id": 394645, "city_id": 11695, "name": "Greeley, CO", "metro_growth_pre": 8.743460659354144, "city_growth_pre": 9.723299373444592, "gap_pre": -0.9798387140904481, "metro_growth_acute": 13.344753144424399, "city_growth_acute": 12.417605655663541, "gap_acute": 0.9271474887608573, "metro_growth_recent": -0.5669727790874088, "city_growth_recent": -0.21045953239924, "gap_recent": -0.35651324668816886 }, { "metro_id": 394808, "city_id": 53060, "name": "Lubbock, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 4.382894081174666, "city_growth_pre": 4.283266238038028, "gap_pre": 0.09962784313663864, "metro_growth_acute": 12.157626438483653, "city_growth_acute": 12.335765184896532, "gap_acute": -0.17813874641287875, "metro_growth_recent": -0.6680080677319831, "city_growth_recent": -0.7453469562405373, "gap_recent": 0.0773388885085542 }, { "metro_id": 394471, "city_id": 10843, "name": "Clarksville, TN", "metro_growth_pre": 3.782789387464025, "city_growth_pre": 3.9649761022904073, "gap_pre": -0.18218671482638227, "metro_growth_acute": 16.042831314884676, "city_growth_acute": 17.097510795826746, "gap_acute": -1.0546794809420703, "metro_growth_recent": 1.3907261883449755, "city_growth_recent": 0.9308468817333713, "gap_recent": 0.45987930661160425 }, { "metro_id": 395028, "city_id": 6792, "name": "Roanoke, VA", "metro_growth_pre": 3.3707160207409887, "city_growth_pre": 3.556201915356715, "gap_pre": -0.1854858946157263, "metro_growth_acute": 12.011863969357574, "city_growth_acute": 12.629873478709158, "gap_acute": -0.6180095093515838, "metro_growth_recent": 4.45552711337139, "city_growth_recent": 4.274072479338876, "gap_recent": 0.18145463403251405 }, { "metro_id": 394579, "city_id": 31471, "name": "Evansville, IN", "metro_growth_pre": 4.590183592884273, "city_growth_pre": 5.000666353403446, "gap_pre": -0.410482760519173, "metro_growth_acute": 10.930935150903947, "city_growth_acute": 11.276967463240736, "gap_acute": -0.34603231233678855, "metro_growth_recent": 4.622431492527044, "city_growth_recent": 4.5211133287630805, "gap_recent": 0.1013181637639633 }, { "metro_id": 394747, "city_id": 32311, "name": "Kingsport, TN", "metro_growth_pre": 4.703674534086671, "city_growth_pre": 5.141661739631462, "gap_pre": -0.43798720554479065, "metro_growth_acute": 13.184681817842481, "city_growth_acute": 13.064918895006905, "gap_acute": 0.11976292283557655, "metro_growth_recent": 4.153998136659638, "city_growth_recent": 3.524303703567553, "gap_recent": 0.6296944330920851 }, { "metro_id": 394741, "city_id": 52747, "name": "Kennewick, WA", "metro_growth_pre": 10.08476764822533, "city_growth_pre": 10.903134104297807, "gap_pre": -0.8183664560724768, "metro_growth_acute": 13.08339505937823, "city_growth_acute": 12.534193718524678, "gap_acute": 0.5492013408535517, "metro_growth_recent": 1.095051394634959, "city_growth_recent": 1.2303465821647521, "gap_recent": -0.1352951875297932 }, { "metro_id": 395179, "city_id": 21017, "name": "Utica, NY", "metro_growth_pre": 4.8876103123286025, "city_growth_pre": 7.199077774715095, "gap_pre": -2.311467462386492, "metro_growth_acute": 12.198150866439155, "city_growth_acute": 13.596728815771227, "gap_acute": -1.398577949332072, "metro_growth_recent": 6.753754680287752, "city_growth_recent": 7.436726200311991, "gap_recent": -0.682971520024239 }, { "metro_id": 394660, "city_id": 38842, "name": "Hagerstown, MD", "metro_growth_pre": 3.967333210566614, "city_growth_pre": 3.8347777963402345, "gap_pre": 0.1325554142263794, "metro_growth_acute": 12.921596530746784, "city_growth_acute": 12.949649046691603, "gap_acute": -0.028052515944818168, "metro_growth_recent": 3.9931216359899975, "city_growth_recent": 3.586415030288681, "gap_recent": 0.40670660570131645 }, { "metro_id": 394543, "city_id": 51758, "name": "Duluth, MN", "metro_growth_pre": 4.303993355193951, "city_growth_pre": 4.502517305909091, "gap_pre": -0.19852395071514017, "metro_growth_acute": 11.369809650970312, "city_growth_acute": 10.688222878649034, "gap_acute": 0.6815867723212783, "metro_growth_recent": 4.5370592229658575, "city_growth_recent": 4.639017780247498, "gap_recent": -0.10195855728164016 }, { "metro_id": 394937, "city_id": 53718, "name": "Olympia, WA", "metro_growth_pre": 8.141548229689283, "city_growth_pre": 7.8404580890127695, "gap_pre": 0.3010901406765134, "metro_growth_acute": 15.142820437327655, "city_growth_acute": 14.384007229806652, "gap_acute": 0.758813207521003, "metro_growth_recent": 1.9211580112303481, "city_growth_recent": 1.7697776205175715, "gap_recent": 0.15138039071277665 }, { "metro_id": 394803, "city_id": 12438, "name": "Longview, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 4.248145825004693, "city_growth_pre": 4.3572785901213695, "gap_pre": -0.10913276511667647, "metro_growth_acute": 9.700544522039033, "city_growth_acute": 9.135144469330044, "gap_acute": 0.5654000527089895, "metro_growth_recent": 1.1145576044701797, "city_growth_recent": 2.191779865272935, "gap_recent": -1.0772222608027553 }, { "metro_id": 395229, "city_id": 21320, "name": "Wilmington, NC", "metro_growth_pre": 5.317811742745599, "city_growth_pre": 5.446866088208362, "gap_pre": -0.1290543454627633, "metro_growth_acute": 16.214457224761613, "city_growth_acute": 15.589559270685069, "gap_acute": 0.6248979540765447, "metro_growth_recent": 1.713136028198038, "city_growth_recent": 1.8284548463136172, "gap_recent": -0.11531881811557931 }, { "metro_id": 395061, "city_id": 6923, "name": "San Luis Obispo, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 5.888785489573581, "city_growth_pre": 5.173224927065321, "gap_pre": 0.7155605625082604, "metro_growth_acute": 13.1070035826782, "city_growth_acute": 10.944707907481908, "gap_acute": 2.162295675196292, "metro_growth_recent": 2.564585669730103, "city_growth_recent": 3.721556308318579, "gap_recent": -1.1569706385884762 }, { "metro_id": 753875, "city_id": 24265, "name": "Crestview, FL", "metro_growth_pre": 5.650862640881884, "city_growth_pre": 6.093126910167776, "gap_pre": -0.442264269285892, "metro_growth_acute": 18.039876876111535, "city_growth_acute": 17.52576951223489, "gap_acute": 0.5141073638766436, "metro_growth_recent": -2.252013242690602, "city_growth_recent": -1.4565027065124465, "gap_recent": -0.7955105361781556 }, { "metro_id": 394851, "city_id": 25855, "name": "Merced, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 8.984443126537805, "city_growth_pre": 8.658607198972422, "gap_pre": 0.3258359275653824, "metro_growth_acute": 15.63415985198885, "city_growth_acute": 16.699130322409182, "gap_acute": -1.0649704704203327, "metro_growth_recent": 1.2406210448071024, "city_growth_recent": 1.3190265181819436, "gap_recent": -0.07840547337484116 }, { "metro_id": 395197, "city_id": 48293, "name": "Waco, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 8.040396940747152, "city_growth_pre": 8.781102733775082, "gap_pre": -0.7407057930279297, "metro_growth_acute": 17.422728798556847, "city_growth_acute": 17.94664069324764, "gap_acute": -0.5239118946907944, "metro_growth_recent": -0.4499333673398137, "city_growth_recent": -1.5643694795176608, "gap_recent": 1.114436112177847 }, { "metro_id": 394447, "city_id": 44506, "name": "Cedar Rapids, IA", "metro_growth_pre": 3.158819007754743, "city_growth_pre": 3.1397905888811146, "gap_pre": 0.019028418873628272, "metro_growth_acute": 8.97338914639527, "city_growth_acute": 8.488617403529759, "gap_acute": 0.4847717428655116, "metro_growth_recent": 3.377267496331805, "city_growth_recent": 3.31763687923168, "gap_recent": 0.05963061710012463 }, { "metro_id": 394348, "city_id": 10201, "name": "Atlantic City, NJ", "metro_growth_pre": 1.696346235410633, "city_growth_pre": 3.5255920662930382, "gap_pre": -1.8292458308824053, "metro_growth_acute": 15.5301973622335, "city_growth_acute": 15.000839043410572, "gap_acute": 0.5293583188229274, "metro_growth_recent": 6.138263861288042, "city_growth_recent": 7.956939381963091, "gap_recent": -1.8186755206750487 }, { "metro_id": 394412, "city_id": 37560, "name": "Bremerton, WA", "metro_growth_pre": 8.856388867848993, "city_growth_pre": 10.599832182208182, "gap_pre": -1.7434433143591885, "metro_growth_acute": 13.60891332191619, "city_growth_acute": 12.822883171032823, "gap_acute": 0.7860301508833683, "metro_growth_recent": 1.8203231578764703, "city_growth_recent": 1.3624826048174512, "gap_recent": 0.45784055305901905 }, { "metro_id": 395103, "city_id": 7087, "name": "Sioux Falls, SD", "metro_growth_pre": 5.200295886697296, "city_growth_pre": 5.260757123910391, "gap_pre": -0.06046123721309549, "metro_growth_acute": 13.065683642308285, "city_growth_acute": 12.984167791772297, "gap_acute": 0.08151585053598787, "metro_growth_recent": 2.4600324891620535, "city_growth_recent": 2.3270825561667277, "gap_recent": 0.13294993299532587 }, { "metro_id": 395065, "city_id": 13715, "name": "Santa Cruz, CA", "metro_growth_pre": 5.831276601358607, "city_growth_pre": 5.572324932011132, "gap_pre": 0.25895166934747493, "metro_growth_acute": 15.409400152156632, "city_growth_acute": 15.936938230071023, "gap_acute": -0.5275380779143912, "metro_growth_recent": 0.9214949278613238, "city_growth_recent": 1.1003408109821826, "gap_recent": -0.1788458831208588 }, { "metro_id": 394572, "city_id": 11335, "name": "Erie, PA", "metro_growth_pre": 2.3936660182499283, "city_growth_pre": 2.1891825393546007, "gap_pre": 0.2044834788953276, "metro_growth_acute": 10.543260884813218, "city_growth_acute": 10.976429153338838, "gap_acute": -0.43316826852561974, "metro_growth_recent": 6.451396779565704, "city_growth_recent": 7.061402763685383, "gap_recent": -0.6100059841196783 }, { "metro_id": 394924, "city_id": 33189, "name": "Norwich, CT", "metro_growth_pre": 2.670277552616313, "city_growth_pre": 3.225099481506151, "gap_pre": -0.554821928889838, "metro_growth_acute": 12.671786323605119, "city_growth_acute": 14.422633280570512, "gap_acute": -1.7508469569653933, "metro_growth_recent": 6.767268100477396, "city_growth_recent": 8.959251073811863, "gap_recent": -2.1919829733344676 }, { "metro_id": 394323, "city_id": 16753, "name": "Amarillo, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 3.400709389222853, "city_growth_pre": 3.461440288121176, "gap_pre": -0.06073089889832284, "metro_growth_acute": 12.71552459976342, "city_growth_acute": 12.797827627096575, "gap_acute": -0.08230302733315575, "metro_growth_recent": 1.8431911767503268, "city_growth_recent": 1.8974530757228256, "gap_recent": -0.05426189897249878 }, { "metro_id": 394772, "city_id": 52893, "name": "Laredo, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 3.5304183478913975, "city_growth_pre": 3.447920227546579, "gap_pre": 0.08249812034481874, "metro_growth_acute": 7.534427797091831, "city_growth_acute": 7.818032239828152, "gap_acute": -0.2836044427363209, "metro_growth_recent": 0.5514991550290241, "city_growth_recent": 0.5863550870569246, "gap_recent": -0.034855932027900494 }, { "metro_id": 395171, "city_id": 14208, "name": "Tuscaloosa, AL", "metro_growth_pre": 2.751187806365073, "city_growth_pre": 2.215634464717654, "gap_pre": 0.5355533416474194, "metro_growth_acute": 9.669181069258237, "city_growth_acute": 9.091423244261032, "gap_acute": 0.5777578249972048, "metro_growth_recent": 0.7502677915628593, "city_growth_recent": 2.013193164754104, "gap_recent": -1.2629253731912446 }, { "metro_id": 394483, "city_id": 37965, "name": "College Station, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 5.003189867267712, "city_growth_pre": 3.7947884079661995, "gap_pre": 1.2084014593015122, "metro_growth_acute": 9.408909445312897, "city_growth_acute": 9.026737897703798, "gap_acute": 0.382171547609099, "metro_growth_recent": 1.2929432160722671, "city_growth_recent": 1.29094754692482, "gap_recent": 0.001995669147447199 }, { "metro_id": 394732, "city_id": 397180, "name": "Kalamazoo, MI", "metro_growth_pre": 5.945169148375968, "city_growth_pre": 8.041515558263871, "gap_pre": -2.0963464098879028, "metro_growth_acute": 10.680312726769866, "city_growth_acute": 11.214146211944282, "gap_acute": -0.5338334851744158, "metro_growth_recent": 3.819344320321847, "city_growth_recent": 4.108474477421727, "gap_recent": -0.2891301570998803 }, { "metro_id": 394811, "city_id": 46348, "name": "Lynchburg, VA", "metro_growth_pre": 3.587907116940417, "city_growth_pre": 4.245531792468514, "gap_pre": -0.6576246755280968, "metro_growth_acute": 11.912355731040444, "city_growth_acute": 11.89253384766342, "gap_acute": 0.019821883377023397, "metro_growth_recent": 3.3819094868422113, "city_growth_recent": 2.831068052062386, "gap_recent": 0.5508414347798252 }, { "metro_id": 394455, "city_id": 17394, "name": "Charleston, WV", "metro_growth_pre": 1.2433824524933812, "city_growth_pre": 0.9978612481066197, "gap_pre": 0.2455212043867615, "metro_growth_acute": 9.36474280085221, "city_growth_acute": 8.497887490539053, "gap_acute": 0.8668553103131558, "metro_growth_recent": 3.1518422062729075, "city_growth_recent": 3.550447252403232, "gap_recent": -0.3986050461303243 }, { "metro_id": 395240, "city_id": 41802, "name": "Yakima, WA", "metro_growth_pre": 8.785271271169353, "city_growth_pre": 8.863402617278066, "gap_pre": -0.07813134610871231, "metro_growth_acute": 11.525610789022899, "city_growth_acute": 10.90352786181133, "gap_acute": 0.6220829272115687, "metro_growth_recent": 2.541093672015781, "city_growth_recent": 2.278686283072534, "gap_recent": 0.262407388943247 }, { "metro_id": 394585, "city_id": 18073, "name": "Fargo, ND", "metro_growth_pre": 3.558556131988544, "city_growth_pre": 3.385415955110973, "gap_pre": 0.17314017687757088, "metro_growth_acute": 6.876107939712191, "city_growth_acute": 5.404287445028207, "gap_acute": 1.4718204946839837, "metro_growth_recent": 2.8012951623097297, "city_growth_recent": 3.3789491850355775, "gap_recent": -0.5776540227258478 }, { "metro_id": 394609, "city_id": 38583, "name": "Fort Smith, AR", "metro_growth_pre": 3.6057242086975534, "city_growth_pre": 2.8028901765139125, "gap_pre": 0.8028340321836409, "metro_growth_acute": 11.854541332088138, "city_growth_acute": 9.136933121478338, "gap_acute": 2.7176082106098, "metro_growth_recent": 3.1834324263540887, "city_growth_recent": 2.307605231597819, "gap_recent": 0.8758271947562699 }, { "metro_id": 394334, "city_id": 30236, "name": "Appleton, WI", "metro_growth_pre": 5.946094603834098, "city_growth_pre": 6.2907903746029, "gap_pre": -0.3446957707688023, "metro_growth_acute": 10.97596817838017, "city_growth_acute": 12.052825019838172, "gap_acute": -1.076856841458003, "metro_growth_recent": 6.2226236673692865, "city_growth_recent": 7.187035003251609, "gap_recent": -0.9644113358823221 }, { "metro_id": 395161, "city_id": 41256, "name": "Topeka, KS", "metro_growth_pre": 4.2226518766845516, "city_growth_pre": 3.5270311968619095, "gap_pre": 0.6956206798226421, "metro_growth_acute": 12.312106132592772, "city_growth_acute": 11.961735980284699, "gap_acute": 0.35037015230807356, "metro_growth_recent": 4.325439414779007, "city_growth_recent": 3.884433323980114, "gap_recent": 0.4410060907988931 }, { "metro_id": 394813, "city_id": 32626, "name": "Macon, GA", "metro_growth_pre": 4.905885060231249, "city_growth_pre": 4.931719287612922, "gap_pre": -0.02583422738167318, "metro_growth_acute": 14.232908277857065, "city_growth_acute": 15.68163848364371, "gap_acute": -1.448730205786644, "metro_growth_recent": 2.251681772269819, "city_growth_recent": 1.6229915870178784, "gap_recent": 0.6286901852519404 }, { "metro_id": 395174, "city_id": 41324, "name": "Tyler, TX", "metro_growth_pre": 4.554926211753442, "city_growth_pre": 4.794135424198207, "gap_pre": -0.23920921244476467, "metro_growth_acute": 13.944888701878858, "city_growth_acute": 13.595055619036374, "gap_acute": 0.3498330828424834, "metro_growth_recent": 0.560356618842523, "city_growth_recent": 0.6246009984896852, "gap_recent": -0.06424437964716223 }, { "metro_id": 394519, "city_id": 14948, "name": "Daphne, AL", "metro_growth_pre": 5.079266273745048, "city_growth_pre": 3.739963195264588, "gap_pre": 1.3393030784804596, "metro_growth_acute": 15.452763636164626, "city_growth_acute": 14.527889704914223, "gap_acute": 0.9248739312504028, "metro_growth_recent": 0.2657994569059159, "city_growth_recent": 0.7920906261413866, "gap_recent": -0.5262911692354707 }, { "metro_id": 394378, "city_id": 50950, "name": "Bellingham, WA", "metro_growth_pre": 9.122591693615702, "city_growth_pre": 9.364462913962942, "gap_pre": -0.24187122034724062, "metro_growth_acute": 14.750812909392874, "city_growth_acute": 14.483371177305472, "gap_acute": 0.2674417320874021, "metro_growth_recent": 2.216735313003994, "city_growth_recent": 2.1769963113813064, "gap_recent": 0.03973900162268773 }, { "metro_id": 394429, "city_id": 37662, "name": "Burlington, VT", "metro_growth_pre": 3.513943412782087, "city_growth_pre": 4.276524843831543, "gap_pre": -0.7625814310494556, "metro_growth_acute": 11.916654784521704, "city_growth_acute": 12.803742655869305, "gap_acute": -0.8870878713476014, "metro_growth_recent": 1.677591308272997, "city_growth_recent": 0.2613798469959937, "gap_recent": 1.4162114612770034 } ] }